Friday, Oct 13, 2023 at 23h BE (17h BO)
AAQC
1. A JC is an academic session where we go through a scientific article for 1 hour.
2. It takes place every Saturday.
3. Its purpose is to understand and discuss relevant elements about the content taking interactive and pedagogic notes (highlighting, underlining and using other learning resources) about the content.
4. We generate further appraisal, identify the opportunities of learning and formulate some potential research questions.
5. We write down the key-points of every session and publish them on our website
6. The article for the next session is posted one week in advance the must-read JC channel of our DISCORD server.
RCT: randomized controlled trial, SL: strengths & limitations, CC: critical care, sRCT: single-center RCT, mRCT: multi center RCT, GL: guidelines, SS: survival, MM: mortality, J: justification, stSIG: statistically significant.
1. ๐๐๐ผ๐ผ๐๐พ แดฎแดผ brief scope: Y, J, C โ T โ N โ t โ PICO:
2. 2023, CC, IT-AUS โ sr โ 19 RCT โ up to Dic 31, 2016 โ PICO:
a. P: CIpxs
b. I: various (sRCT w_โSS)
c. C: various
d. O: statistically significant MM
3. R โฉ 16 sRCT = 16 mRCT โฉ 1 mRCT โ โ 14 mRCT NEUTRAL โ 1 mRCT โ
4. IN: stat. Significant + >48h โ PubMed (NEJM, JAMA, LANCET)
5. sOC: Careful with GL: 19 sRCT = 14 GL โฉ 6 USE โ 2 INSUF. EVIDENCE โ 6 CONTRAINDICATED
6.sRCTs was rarely confirmed by mRCT in ICU settings.
7. SL:
a. S: 1st to identify sRCT w_stsig โ MM
b. S: Novel approach to evaluate impact on GL
c. L: Just in ICU, not translated to other disciplines
d. L: Published until 2016, recent excluded
e. J: median duration between sRCT and mRCT publication was 8 years,
f. L: Specialty journals were excluded
g. L: Small number of studies
h. L: Confined to international GL
8. sRCTs need to be perceived as hypothesis-generating
9. Clinicians should be cautious in altering routine clinical practices until well-conducted multicenter randomized trials are available.
10. Careful with RECOMMENDATION based on SOLELY โ sRCTs
โณTIME MANAGEMENT
42:10:10 in total
Round: 6 00:02:96 Final
Round: 5 04:37:34 Final notes
Round: 4 20:41:18 Conclusions + wrap-up
Round: 3 07:04:24 Images + tables
Round: 2 09:28:78 Structure
Round: 1 00:15:57 45 min โฉ article overview
โก๏ธ = cardiac arrest, ๐ค = analysis, ๐จ = flow, ๐ = arrhythmia, ๐ฃ = suggestion(s), ๐ฉธ = blood = hematology, ๐ชฒ = infections, ๐ง = brain, ๐ซ = heart, ๐ซ = lungs, ๐ซ๐ฝ = abdomen = abdominal, โพ๏ธ = kidneys = renal, โธ = liver = hepatic, โฐ = pressure, ๐ช๐ฝ = muscle, โญ๏ธ = circulation, ๐ฅ = inflammation, โ = recommendation(s), โ = increase, โ = decrease, โ๏ธ = improve, โ๏ธ = worsen, ๐๐ซ = exclusion, ๐๐ก = inclusion, CIpxs = critically ill patients, DX = diagnosis, h_LOS = Hospital length of stay, icu_LOS = ICU length of stay, inc_ = incident, MA = metaanalysis, mc = multicentric, MM = mortality, MM90 = mortality at 90 days, pOC = primary outcome(s), pxs = patients, RCT = randomized controlled trial, sOC = secondary outcome(s), sr = systematic review, SS = survival, w_ = with, wo_ = without, yo = years old
๐๐๐ผ๐ผ๐๐พ แดฎแดผ brief scope
๐๐๐พ-S ๐ฐ ๐๐๐ผ๐ผ๐๐พ แดฎแดผ scope ๐ฐ Y, J, C โ T โ N โ t โ P I C O:
year (Y), journal (J), country (C) โ type of study (T) โ number of patients/sample (N) โ time (t) โpopulation (P), intervention (I), comparison (C), outcome (O, OC).
Complete glossary here